28 February 2009

The Standings

One of the great beauties of baseball is that it's so unpredictable. Every year, a team or two that appear moribund make play0ff runs. The Rays and Cards of '08 come to mind. Conversely, some squad that's stacked, tanks. 2008's Detroit and Cleveland are exemplars.

Paradoxically, that makes pre-season projections so much fun. The one below is from Baseball Projection, which uses a system called CHONE (named facetiously for creator Sean Smith) to project the most likely performance from each player in the league, estimate his playing time, and then aggregate all that for each team. It calculates the resulting runs scored versus runs allowed and then uses the Pythagorean formula to project the team's record.

The shortcomings of this method (or any projection made prior to Opening Day) are so transparent as to belie comment. But the projections do give us a guide as to which teams appear stonger or weaker than you might have thought at first glance. Keep in mind that these projections don't include Manny Ramirez's signing or any trades/signings/injuries after February 24.


American
East W L Central W L West W L
Yankees 97 65 Indians 90 72 Angels 85 77
Red Sox 96 66 Tigers 85 77 A's 81 81
Rays 89 73 Twins 79 83 Mariners 78 84
Blue Jays 75 87 White Sox 73 89 Rangers 72 90
Orioles 74 88 Royals 72 90
National
East W L Central W L West W L
Phillies 87 75 Cubs 88 74 Dodgers 82 80
Braves 86 76 Cardinals 83 79 Padres 80 82
Mets 86 76 Reds 82 80 D-Backs 79 83
Marlins 75 87 Brewers 81 81 Rockies 78 84
Nationals 74 88 Pirates 73 89 Giants 77 85
Astros 72 90

Remember that these are "average" projections; i.e., there is an equal chance according to this system that each team will win either more or fewer than the number of games listed. So, for example, the Rays may have more upside than the Yanks and Sox, but more downside as well. 89 wins is the midpoint.

I personally believe that the Mets should be a narrow favorite in the NL East and that the Indians and Mariners are vastly overrated by this system. I think the Royals are improving and would bet real American legal tender that they don't have the worst record in baseball. I'm surprised by the lack of respect for the Cubs in a weak NL Central, but not surprised at all by the tossup nature of the NL West.

Take it for what it's worth.

No comments: